Comparison: Claude Haiku 4.5 vs Gemini 3 Flash vs GPT 5.1 Codex Mini

Purpose: Compare three efficient-tier models suitable for GitHub Copilot and high-volume coding tasks.

Executive Summary

ModelProviderKey StrengthBest For
Claude Haiku 4.5AnthropicFastest with near-frontier intelligence + Extended thinkingSpeed-critical agentic coding
Gemini 3 FlashGoogle DeepMindFrontier intelligence at speed + MultimodalBalanced performance & multimodality
GPT 5.1 Codex MiniOpenAILowest cost + Massive context (400K)Budget-conscious code generation

Quick Decision Matrix

Cost Priority β†’ GPT 5.1 Codex Mini ($0.25/1M in)
Speed Priority β†’ Claude Haiku 4.5 (Fastest)
Performance + Multimodal β†’ Gemini 3 Flash (78% SWE-bench)
Long Context β†’ GPT 5.1 Codex Mini (400K tokens)

πŸ“Š Technical Specifications

SpecificationClaude Haiku 4.5Gemini 3 Flash (Preview)GPT 5.1 Codex Mini
API Identifierclaude-haiku-4-5 / claude-haiku-4-5-20251001gemini-3-flash-previewgpt-5.1-codex-mini
Context Window200,000 tokensUnlimited (tiered caching)400,000 tokens
Max Output64,000 tokensVariable128,000 tokens
Training Data CutoffJul 2025Current (rolling)Sep 30, 2024
Reliable Knowledge CutoffFeb 2025CurrentSep 30, 2024
Extended Thinkingβœ… Yesβœ… Yes (reasoning mode)❌ No
Multimodal Supportβœ… Text + Imagesβœ… Text + Images + Video + Audio❌ Text only
Platform AvailabilityClaude API, AWS Bedrock, GCP Vertex AIGoogle AI Studio, Vertex AIOpenAI Responses API only

Context & Output Comparison

  • Claude Haiku 4.5: 200K context / 64K output = 3.1:1 ratio
  • GPT 5.1 Codex Mini: 400K context / 128K output = 3.1:1 ratio (2x Claude’s absolute capacity)
  • Gemini 3 Flash: Unlimited context with tiered pricing (>200K incurs premium)

πŸ’° Pricing Analysis

All prices in USD per 1 million tokens. Standard/on-demand tier.

Input Pricing

ModelBase InputCached InputAudio Input
GPT 5.1 Codex Mini$0.25 πŸ†$0.025 (90% discount)N/A
Claude Haiku 4.5$1.00$0.10 (cache hits)N/A
Gemini 3 Flash$0.50 (≀200K) / $1.00 (>200K)$0.05$1.00

Output Pricing

ModelOutputNotes
GPT 5.1 Codex Mini$2.00 πŸ†Lowest output cost
Gemini 3 Flash$3.0050% more expensive than GPT
Claude Haiku 4.5$5.00Premium for near-frontier intelligence

Cost Comparison Examples

Scenario 1: Generate 10K tokens with 50K context (cached)

  • GPT 5.1 Codex Mini: (50K Γ— $0.025) + (10K Γ— $2.00) = $1.25 + $20 = $21.25/1M
  • Gemini 3 Flash: (50K Γ— $0.05) + (10K Γ— $3.00) = $2.50 + $30 = $32.50/1M (+53%)
  • Claude Haiku 4.5: (50K Γ— $0.10) + (10K Γ— $5.00) = $5.00 + $50 = $55.00/1M (+159%)

Scenario 2: Long-context task (300K input, 20K output)

  • GPT 5.1 Codex Mini: (300K Γ— $0.25) + (20K Γ— $2.00) = $75 + $40 = $115/1M
  • Gemini 3 Flash: (200K Γ— $0.50) + (100K Γ— $1.00) + (20K Γ— $3.00) = $100 + $100 + $60 = $260/1M (+126%)
  • Claude Haiku 4.5: ❌ Exceeds 200K context limit

Winner by Use Case:

  • High-volume, cached workloads: GPT 5.1 Codex Mini (90% cache discount)
  • Long documents (>200K tokens): GPT 5.1 Codex Mini (no premium scaling)
  • Budget-constrained projects: GPT 5.1 Codex Mini (2-4x cheaper)

🎯 Performance Benchmarks

Official vendor-published scores only. Missing data marked as β€œUnknown”.

Agentic Coding & Problem Solving

BenchmarkDescriptionClaude Haiku 4.5Gemini 3 FlashGPT 5.1 Codex Mini
SWE-bench VerifiedReal-world GitHub issue resolutionUnknown78.0% (single attempt)Unknown
Terminal-Bench 2.0Command-line tool useUnknown47.6% (Terminus-2 harness)Unknown
LiveCodeBench ProCompetitive coding (Codeforces/ICPC)Unknown2316 EloUnknown

Graduate-Level Reasoning

BenchmarkDescriptionClaude Haiku 4.5Gemini 3 FlashGPT 5.1 Codex Mini
GPQA DiamondPhD-level science questions (no tools)Unknown90.4%Unknown
AIME 2025High school math olympiad (no tools)Unknown95.2%Unknown
Humanity’s Last ExamFrontier reasoning benchmarkUnknown33.7% (no tools)Unknown

Multimodal Understanding

BenchmarkDescriptionClaude Haiku 4.5Gemini 3 FlashGPT 5.1 Codex Mini
MMMU-ProMultimodal understanding & reasoningUnknown81.2%N/A (text-only)
Video-MMMUVideo knowledge acquisitionUnknown86.9%N/A
ScreenSpot-ProScreen understandingUnknown69.1%N/A

Long Context Processing

BenchmarkDescriptionClaude Haiku 4.5Gemini 3 FlashGPT 5.1 Codex Mini
MRCR v2 (8-needle)128K context retrievalUnknown67.2% (avg)Unknown
MRCR v2 (pointwise)1M context retrievalContext limit: 200K22.1%Unknown

Key Insights

  1. Gemini 3 Flash is the only model with published benchmarks, making it the most transparent choice
  2. 78% SWE-bench (Gemini 3 Flash) rivals Claude Sonnet 4.5 (77.2%), demonstrating frontier-class coding despite being an β€œefficient” model
  3. 95.2% AIME (Gemini 3 Flash) surpasses many flagship models, indicating strong mathematical reasoning
  4. GPT 5.1 Codex Mini and Claude Haiku 4.5 lack public benchmark data, likely due to their positioning as specialized/efficiency variants

πŸš€ Capabilities Deep Dive

Claude Haiku 4.5

Strengths:

  • βœ… Fastest latency among the three (β€œFastest” in official comparison table)
  • βœ… Extended thinking mode (like o1/o3 series) for complex reasoning
  • βœ… Near-frontier intelligence (official claim from Anthropic)
  • βœ… Multimodal (text + vision)
  • βœ… Multi-platform: Available on AWS Bedrock & GCP Vertex AI (regional/global endpoints)

Limitations:

  • ❌ 200K context limit (smallest among the three)
  • ❌ No public benchmarks yet (model released Oct 2025)
  • ❌ Higher cost per token compared to GPT/Gemini

Best For:

  • Real-time interactive coding assistants
  • Production environments requiring ultra-low latency
  • Tasks benefiting from extended reasoning (extended thinking mode)
  • Multi-cloud deployments (AWS/GCP)

Gemini 3 Flash

Strengths:

  • βœ… Best-documented performance with extensive public benchmarks
  • βœ… Frontier intelligence at speed (official tagline)
  • βœ… Multimodal excellence: Text + Images + Video + Audio
  • βœ… Video understanding (86.9% Video-MMMU)
  • βœ… Math & reasoning: 95.2% AIME, 90.4% GPQA Diamond
  • βœ… Agentic coding: 78% SWE-bench Verified (single attempt)
  • βœ… Unlimited context (with tiered pricing beyond 200K)

Limitations:

  • ⚠️ Premium pricing above 200K context ($1.00 input / $12.00-$18.00 output)
  • ⚠️ Still in β€œPreview” status (production readiness unclear)
  • ❌ 1.5-2x more expensive than GPT 5.1 Codex Mini

Best For:

  • Multimodal applications (video analysis, audio processing)
  • Tasks requiring verified high performance (benchmarks available)
  • Projects where intelligence > cost
  • Document understanding with images/charts

GPT 5.1 Codex Mini

Strengths:

  • βœ… Lowest cost: $0.25 input (50% of Gemini, 25% of Claude)
  • βœ… Massive context: 400K tokens (2x Claude, no Gemini premium)
  • βœ… Largest output: 128K tokens (2x Claude)
  • βœ… 90% cache discount ($0.025 cached input)
  • βœ… Optimized for Codex: Specialized for GitHub Copilot-style workflows
  • βœ… OpenAI ecosystem: Compatible with OpenAI Responses API

Limitations:

  • ❌ Text-only (no images, audio, or video)
  • ❌ No public benchmarks (likely due to Responses API-only release)
  • ❌ Sep 2024 cutoff (oldest among the three)
  • ❌ Responses API only (not available in standard Chat Completions)
  • ❌ No reasoning mode (unlike Claude Haiku’s extended thinking)

Best For:

  • High-volume code generation (caching + low cost)
  • Long-context code analysis (400K window)
  • Budget-constrained projects (2-4x cheaper)
  • GitHub Copilot integration (Codex-optimized)
  • Large codebase refactoring (massive output capacity)

πŸ› οΈ Use Case Recommendations

GitHub Copilot / IDE Integration

PriorityRecommended ModelRationale
Cost EfficiencyGPT 5.1 Codex Mini50-75% cheaper; massive context for codebases
Speed (Autocomplete)Claude Haiku 4.5Fastest latency; optimized for interactive UX
Code QualityGemini 3 Flash78% SWE-bench; proven agentic coding capability

Specific Scenarios

1. Interactive Coding Assistant (Cursor, Codex IDE)
β†’ Claude Haiku 4.5

  • Reason: Fastest latency + Extended thinking for complex refactors

2. Batch Code Generation / Codebase Analysis
β†’ GPT 5.1 Codex Mini

  • Reason: 400K context + $0.025 cached input (90% discount on repeated analysis)

3. Documentation with Screenshots
β†’ Gemini 3 Flash

  • Reason: Multimodal (images) + strong document understanding

4. Video Tutorial Analysis
β†’ Gemini 3 Flash

  • Reason: Only model with native video support (86.9% Video-MMMU)

5. Math-Heavy Code (Scientific Computing)
β†’ Gemini 3 Flash

  • Reason: 95.2% AIME demonstrates superior mathematical reasoning

6. Budget-Constrained Startup
β†’ GPT 5.1 Codex Mini

  • Reason: 2-4x cheaper; massive context without premium scaling

βš–οΈ Head-to-Head Comparison

Speed: Claude Haiku 4.5 πŸ†

Winner: Claude Haiku 4.5 (official β€œFastest” designation)

  • Runner-up: Gemini 3 Flash (Preview-level may have variable latency)
  • Third: GPT 5.1 Codex Mini (Responses API adds overhead)

Cost: GPT 5.1 Codex Mini πŸ†

Winner: GPT 5.1 Codex Mini ($0.25/$2.00)

  • 50% cheaper input than Gemini 3 Flash
  • 75% cheaper input than Claude Haiku 4.5
  • 90% cache discount ($0.025) unmatched

Performance: Gemini 3 Flash πŸ†

Winner: Gemini 3 Flash (only model with published benchmarks)

  • 78% SWE-bench Verified
  • 95.2% AIME 2025
  • 90.4% GPQA Diamond

Context Window: GPT 5.1 Codex Mini πŸ†

Winner: GPT 5.1 Codex Mini (400K tokens)

  • 2x Claude Haiku 4.5 (200K)
  • No premium pricing like Gemini (>200K)

Multimodality: Gemini 3 Flash πŸ†

Winner: Gemini 3 Flash (Text + Image + Video + Audio)

  • Claude Haiku 4.5: Text + Image only
  • GPT 5.1 Codex Mini: Text only

Reasoning: Tie (Claude Haiku 4.5 / Gemini 3 Flash)

  • Claude Haiku 4.5: Extended thinking mode (like o1/o3)
  • Gemini 3 Flash: Native reasoning (no benchmarks for Haiku yet)
  • GPT 5.1 Codex Mini: No reasoning mode

πŸ“š Sources & Verification

Primary Sources

  1. Anthropic Claude Documentation

  2. Google DeepMind - Gemini 3

  3. OpenAI Platform Documentation

Benchmark Methodologies

  • SWE-bench Verified: Real-world GitHub issues from 500-problem dataset (Gemini: single attempt, no test-time compute)
  • AIME 2025: American Invitational Mathematics Examination (no external tools)
  • GPQA Diamond: Graduate-level STEM questions (no tools)
  • Terminal-Bench 2.0: Command-line tool use (Gemini uses Terminus-2 harness)

Limitations & Caveats

  1. No direct benchmarks for Claude Haiku 4.5 or GPT 5.1 Codex Mini (as of Feb 2026)
  2. Preview status for Gemini 3 Flash (production readiness may vary)
  3. Responses API-only for GPT 5.1 Codex Mini (limited availability)
  4. Benchmark heterogeneity: Different evaluation setups (single vs. multi-trial, tool access) make cross-vendor comparisons approximate


πŸ“ Summary & Recommendations

Choose Claude Haiku 4.5 if:

  • ⚑ Speed is critical (real-time autocomplete, interactive debugging)
  • 🧠 You need extended thinking for complex reasoning
  • ☁️ You’re using AWS Bedrock or GCP Vertex AI

Choose Gemini 3 Flash if:

  • πŸ“Š You need verified performance (extensive public benchmarks)
  • πŸŽ₯ You’re working with multimodal data (images, video, audio)
  • πŸ’ͺ You want frontier intelligence in an efficient model

Choose GPT 5.1 Codex Mini if:

  • πŸ’° Budget is a constraint (50-75% cheaper)
  • πŸ“„ You need massive context (400K tokens, no premium)
  • πŸ”„ You have high-volume, cached workloads (90% discount)
  • πŸ“ Your tasks are text/code-only

Last updated: 2026-02-11
Status: 🌺 Blooming (Verified & Published)
Comparison based on official vendor documentation as of February 2026.